Giving Money Away and Keeping an Income
A charitable gift annuity is a simple bargain: you hand a charity a lump sum, and it pays you a fixed amount for the rest of your life, keeping whatever remains. It produces a deduction now, an income that partly escapes tax, and a gift the charity can count on. It also hands over capital permanently, which is the part that has to be understood before anything is signed.
- Fixed payments for life:: The rate is set at the outset and does not change with markets.
- Deduction is the net gift:: Only the excess of the gift over the value of the payments is deductible.
- Payments are partly untaxed:: Part of each payment is a return of the investment for a period.
- The capital does not come back:: There is nothing left for heirs from the amount given.
Where the AI summary above gets this wrong
"A charitable gift annuity gives you a tax deduction for the full amount you give."
That's surface-true. Here's what it misses:
- The deduction is only the part the charity keeps — Because the donor receives payments in return, the deduction is the value of the transfer less the present value of those payments. On a typical arrangement that is a fraction of the amount handed over, and a donor expecting a deduction for the whole sum will be disappointed.
- The payment rate is not an investment return — Rates offered are higher than a bond yield partly because each payment is returning some of your own capital. Comparing the rate to a portfolio's yield is comparing two different things, and the money is gone at death rather than passing to heirs or to further giving.
- An IRA can fund one, once — A one-time qualified charitable distribution can be made to fund a gift annuity, within a separate limit and subject to conditions. For someone with required distributions and no need for the money, that route converts a taxable distribution into a lifetime income and a gift in a single step.
01 The bargain
The donor transfers cash or securities to a charity. In exchange the charity contracts to pay a fixed amount, usually quarterly or annually, for the life of the donor or of the donor and a spouse. Whatever remains at death belongs to the charity.
Rates are typically based on a schedule published for the sector and rise with the age of the recipient, since an older donor is expected to receive fewer payments. The rate is fixed at the outset and does not change.
The payment is a general obligation of the charity rather than a segregated fund, so the charity's own financial strength matters. That is worth asking about, and few donors do.
Shows: the income a gift annuity pays over the years you expect to receive it, at the rate the charity offers. Ignores: the charitable deduction available in the year of the gift, how much of each payment is taxable, inflation, and the fact that payments stop at death.
02 The deduction and the tax on the payments
Because the donor receives something back, the deduction is the value of what was transferred less the present value of the payments. The charity provides that calculation, and it is generally a minority of the amount given.
Part of each payment is treated as a tax-free return of the investment over an expected period, with the remainder taxable. Where appreciated securities funded the annuity, part of the gain is spread across the payments rather than realised at once.
The usual substantiation applies: a written acknowledgement from the charity describing the annuity received in exchange, without which the deduction fails regardless of the arithmetic.
03 Funding one from an IRA
A qualified charitable distribution can be used once to fund a charitable gift annuity, within its own limit and subject to conditions on the annuity's terms. The distribution is excluded from income rather than deducted.
For someone taking required distributions they do not need, that is an efficient route: money that would have been taxable becomes a lifetime income and a completed gift, without the distribution appearing in income at all.
The conditions are specific and the opportunity is one-time, so this is a decision to take with the charity's gift officer and your own adviser together rather than from a brochure.
04 Who it suits and who it does not
It suits a donor who already intends to give to that charity, wants income, and is content that the capital will not return. The combination of those three is narrower than the marketing suggests.
It suits poorly anyone who might need the capital back, anyone whose main aim is leaving money to family, and anyone comparing the rate against an investment return without noticing that the capital is being consumed to produce it.
For a donor who wants flexibility about which charities benefit and when, a donor-advised fund or a straightforward distribution direct to charity each year does the giving without the annuity contract attached.
Only do this with a charity you were going to support anyway, and only with money you are certain you will not need back. The rate looks generous next to a bond because part of every payment is your own capital coming home — that is not a criticism of the product, it is what the product is. If the appeal is the income rather than the gift, you want a commercial annuity, and if the appeal is the gift, this is a good way to make one.
FAQ
How much of a gift annuity is deductible?
The value of what you transfer less the present value of the payments you will receive. That is generally a minority of the amount given, not the whole sum.
Are the payments taxable?
Partly. Part of each payment is a tax-free return of the investment for an expected period, with the remainder taxable. Funding with appreciated securities spreads part of the gain across the payments.
Can I fund one from my IRA?
A one-time qualified charitable distribution can fund a gift annuity, within a separate limit and subject to conditions on the annuity's terms.
Sources
Regulator references
- Publication 526: Charitable contributions · Internal Revenue Service · 2026How a gift that returns something to the donor is deducted.Last verified: 2026-09-07
- Charitable contribution deductions · Internal Revenue Service · 2026The limits and substantiation the deduction depends on.Last verified: 2026-09-07
- Retirement plans FAQs regarding IRA distributions · Internal Revenue Service · 2026The qualified charitable distribution route into a gift annuity.Last verified: 2026-09-07
Calculator unit tests · the assertions this page's worked example is checked against, and their last result
Changelog
- 2026-09-07 — initial publish (new format)
Run this rule against your situation
See what this rule does to your own projection — month by month, to age 90.
Join the Waitlist
Jordan Reeves
Founder of Talk Through Wealth. A software engineer for over a decade before turning to retirement planning, Jordan built the projection engine after watching family members get fragmented, country-by-country advice that never reconciled. He writes about retirement the way the engine computes it: month-by-month, lifetime-long, and skeptical of any rule of thumb that hasn't been run through the math.